Weight Loss & Fitness Blog | Weight Reduction Coach header image 2

Beef, it’s what’s for dinner…or is it?

November 14th, 2007 by Lindy Kirk · 4 Comments

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

Americans are obsessed with weight and weight loss. Much of this is due to our idea of the ideal body type. Hollywood has skewed our thinking and brainwashed many of us into believing rail-thin, bony frames are the epitome of beauty. Females compare themselves to the starlets they see in movies, TV and magazines. Men are also held to high standards while trying to balance a lean and muscular combination. Guys like Brad and Leo make this seem extremely appealing, as well as simple.

Due to our thinking, many Americans are constantly concocting and following new and bizarre diets. From carb-free to sugar-free to spending 2 weeks consuming only liquids while having colon-cleansings each of the 14 days, fad dieters, and the menu they follow, keep me constantly scratching my head in confusion.  While these are blatantly outrageous and appear to set the victim up for failure from day one, there are some ways of eating that are tricky and deceiving.

A prime example of one of these is vegetarianism. Wait…before you clench your fists and declare me ignorant, let me elaborate. Living a vegetarian lifestyle is wonderful, and when done right, is extremely healthy and beneficial. It is not, however, a diet. Diets are meant to be temporary, and becoming a vegetarian is usually a long-term or life-long switch. Another issue is that upon this conversion to the meatless church, you are not necessarily cutting a bazillion calories and exponentially reducing your fat content. The aspects of food that add or subtract pounds do not automatically disappear when you trade your meat in for Boca. In fact, many unsuspecting souls find themselves gaining weight from their diet change. But why, you ask? After all, eliminating fattening foods like red meat and pork should instigate a fat-melting effect, right? Wrong. Most vegetarians subtract meat from their dinner plate, but continue to eat dairy and eggs.

Ok, let’s think about this logically. When a person, let’s call him Bob, eliminates something from his life, let’s say soda, he is most likely going to fill the void in some way. Whether this is drowning himself with water or iced tea or counting the tiles on the kitchen floor, it doesn’t matter. The point is, when you lose one thing, you often compensate by adding another, or increasing the frequency or quantity of an existing thing. So, let’s apply this to our novice vegetarian. Meat is lost, so consumption of cheese, pasta, bread, or other fatty and high-carb edibles increases. Those who set down this path with caution and knowledge know to avoid this slippery slope of compensation and void-filling. These smarties will curve their appetites with healthy goodies like raw veggies, roasted almonds or an apple with a dab of peanut butter. The less informed newbies will satiate their hunger with cheese or bread, both of which are fine in moderation, but can pack on the pounds if frequently consumed in somewhat large amounts.

So, what have we learned? Vegetarianism is a GREAT lifestyle choice, but it is just that, a lifestyle. It should not be used solely for the purpose of losing weight. Most vegetarians have made their decision for ethical or health reasons, so please do not trivialize this choice with pure vanity. Next, if you create a well-balanced, high protein and high fiber vegetarian diet, you may very well lose weight, but these are not rapid results. It takes time for your body to adjust to the new fuel you are pumping into it. So, for you serial dieters, there is no instant gratification in this method. Lastly, there is no guarantee that you will lose any weight at all, despite how long you stick it out. If you cave and give into cravings or temptation, chances are, you’ll fill your meat void with an even unhealthier substitute. If you are wanting to make the switch, I say go for it. Think over your reasons and make sure they are valid and realistic. Don’t lie to yourself regarding your primary motivators. This is a fairly tough lifestyle to take on and maintain, so be sure you’ve given it a lot of consideration. Next, talk to other veggies, nutritionists or someone with some knowledge of the do’s and don’ts of a meat-free diet. Have them teach you the proper amounts of protein, fats, carbs, etc you should be eating. Create a well-balanced diet that incorporates foods or supplements that will compensate for the lack of meat. Be smart about it. If you jump into this and just start haphazardly eliminating meat, you will wind up overweight or underweight, and all around unhealthy.

Tags: Articles

Related Post

  • No Related Post

4 responses so far ↓

  • 1 DJ // Nov 15, 2007 at 5:10 am

    I wanted to express my appreciation for this article as well as correct a mistake you made that is of great importance to understanding and maintaining a weight loss program.

    The fact that you can openly and respectfully promote the vegetarian lifestyle is commendable as many people dismiss it as “tree hugging, animal rights junk” as I most recently heard it referred to. While most of the facts you presented about the vegetarian lifestyle are true I can not, and will not, ever agree that is it a healthier lifestyle than that which the human body was created/evolved for. We are omnivours by biology.

    I must, however correct your statement that “Diets are meant to be temporary…” The definition of a diet is the way you normally eat or a permanent change to the way you eat. They are not temporary. While many will argue the semantics of those statements, it is the truth.

    It is also crucial to the success or failure of any weight loss program. To admit, identify and correct your eating habits is the single most important thing anyone can do to ensure the achievement of their goals. It is also crucial to the maintaining of their desired results once achieved. It does no good to change the way you eat and lose 25 pounds only to go back to how you used to eat and gain it all back.

    DJ Friedman
    Chef and Nutritionist

  • 2 Jeff Wilson // Nov 15, 2007 at 10:11 am

    Very interesting post Lindy, I’m a vegetarian (about 5 years) and I vocalize many of the points you made here on a regular basis.

    It’s a little aggrevating when people dive into what they think is vegetarianism like a fad diet that will magically melt fat away immediatley, then try to survive on french fries and ice cream.

    No one seems to realize, when it comes to dieting or lifestyle changes, the most important thing you can do is educate yourself before jumping into anything.

  • 3 Lindy Kirk // Nov 15, 2007 at 6:19 pm

    DJ,

    Thank you very much for your comments. I appreciate the correction, and completely understand your point. The “diet” mistake was a case of semantics, and I misused the word “diet” when saying it’s meant to be temporary. I should have chosen my words more carefully.
    As for calling vegetarianism “healthier,” I should not have generalized. I had many digestive problems that I used to contribute to my MS. After a suggestion for my Dr, I switched to vegetarianism, and it ended up being healthier for me and my body–and my previous diet was healthy in irs own right. So, for many people, cutting out meat, dairy, eggs or whatever is a healthier lifestyle, as everybody is different and is affected by certain foods differently. Example: We are meant to drink milk, i.e. breast milk, yet many people are lactose intolerant. Just because we are meant to eat something, it doesn’t mean everybody is meant to.
    I did, however, really enjoy your comments and welcome any opinions, be them agreeing or disagreeing!

  • 4 Lindy Kirk // Nov 15, 2007 at 6:23 pm

    Jeff,
    Thanks for your feedback! I get frustrated, as well, when people look to a semi-vegetarian diet for an easy fix for weight issues. I do think it goes to show that in order to maintain this lifestyle, there must be more motivation behind it than merely weight loss. Most veggies I know are working toward a cause, whether it ethical, health or what not. The tenuous link is most veggies are passionate about their way of life, and this is wha keeps them on the wagon.

Leave a Comment